Scoop Review of Books

Pacific Slavers

The Stolen Island: Searching for ‘Ata

by Scott Hamilton (BWB Texts, paper $14.99; e-book $4.99)

Reviewed by Michael Horowitz

stolen_island_coverLocated even further south than temperate Noumea, Tonga’s tiny island of ‘Ata might have become the jewel of the kingdom’s burgeoning tourist industry. Imagine a Tongan resort that would not only be mild in winter, but pleasant in summer.

Alas, it was not to be. As Scott Hamilton poignantly describes in his concise account, Stolen Island, an Australian whaler anchored offshore in June 1863 … tricked nearly half the island’s over 300 inhabitants to come aboard to trade … then locked the exits and delivered them to a slave ship bound for Peru. Shortly after their arrival in port, the Peruvian government enforced its abolition of slavery and ordered all captured islanders, including Tahitians and Tongans, repatriated. Yet the prisoners were again betrayed: this time by being labelled a medical threat by the captain of the returning vessel and dumped on remote Cocos island, where all but 38 perished. Finally in November, a Peruvian warship brought survivors to the seaside village of Paita, where the descendants of some ‘Atans may possibly carry on today.

Before continuing this review, a word about the author, Hamilton, already known to many who track this site. Scott earned a PhD in sociology from the University of Auckland in 2009 on the strength of a cogent critique of E.P. Thompson, an independent British socialist of the last half of the 20th century; remarkably, the study was published by the University of Manchester within three years of Hamilton’s defence. Following publication, Hamilton joined me for a year as associate dean at Tonga’s ‘Atenisi Institute, Polynesia’s innovative academy. Currently he’s collaborating with AUT filmmaker Paul Janman on a history of the Great South Road, after receiving a literary grant from Auckland’s mayor to also chronicle the artery in print.

Back to ‘Ata. After learning of the abduction, Tonga’s king shipped its remaining residents to the island of ‘Eua, within sight of the island of Tongatapu, on which the capital Nuku’alofa is located. The second half of Stolen Island speculates both about the descendants of those transferred to Peru and those relocated in ‘Eua: Can those in Paita be traced? Have they prospered? How do ‘Atans in ‘Eua differ from indigenous ‘Euans? (To confirm the flexuous journey of his people, Masalu Halahala, chief of the ‘Atan village on ‘Eua, greeted Kiwi literati at Stolen Island’s recent launch.)

Hamilton’s kinetic capsule sweeps like a tornado siphoning Lapita settlement, Dutch exploration, South American slavery, Down Under servitude, infectious disease, Kiwi justice, Tongan gossip, and the adventure travel of an intrepid Spaniard. Yet at the end of the day ‘tis ‘Ata that remains – a rocky isle, now uninhabited, with its 18th century ruins glimmering in the subtropical sun, as your Airbus hurtles you to bustling Auckland.


michael_horowitzpicMichael Horowitz resumed as university dean of Tonga’s ‘Atenisi Institute in 2015. His articles on Pacific politics and society have appeared in the Journal of Pacific History, Pacific Affairs, and Sites. He is currently summer Research Fellow at AUT’s Pacific Media Centre.


Click here to read reviews of other books in the BWB Texts series.